Who doesn’t remember the classic scene from American Pie with Jim and his dad are sitting awkwardly at the kitchen table after the movie’s namesake incident occurred; I can only imagine what Jim must have felt as his dad slowly turns to him and says, as if it’s the only answer: ”We’ll just tell your mother that… we ate it all.” Jim, you’ve got a cool dad.

In honor of American Pie gang getting together for the release of American Reunion, we salute the best Pies in New York, we promise you wont be lying when you tell your mom that you really ate it all!

I’m In The Kitchen’s Best Pies in the City:

Four and Twenty Blackbirds: Double Crusted Apple Pie
Yura on Madison: Blueberry Pie
Two Little Red Hens: Chocolate pecan pie
Little Pie Company: Sour Cream Apple Pie
Sweet Melissa: Lemon Meringue Tart
The Dutch: Cherry Pie
Bubby’s Pie Company: Michigan Sour Cherry Pie
Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pies: Swingles (aka Key Lime Pie on a Stick)
First Prize Pies: S’mores Pie
Hill Country Chicken: Classic Apple Pie with Cheddar Lattice Crust